In every market clients narrow their options before they ever make a decision. That short list is where everything happens.
If a general counsel, business owner, or referral source is looking for a lawyer, they are not interviewing every firm in town. They will look at three or four names, talk to a couple of people, and make a choice. If you are not on that short list, your odds of getting the work are zero.
Most lawyers understand this idea, but many still behave as if great legal skills alone will somehow move them into consideration. Now we add AI into the mix, and there is a new, dangerous assumption that the tools will magically surface clients and opportunities. That is not how it works.
Clients are already experimenting with AI. They might ask a tool things like, “Who are the top employment lawyers for tech companies in Austin” or “Which firms specialize in complex commercial litigation in Texas” or “Explain the reputation of Firm X in venture deals.” AI does not invent names out of thin air. It looks at what is already visible. Your website, your bio, your articles, the podcasts where you show up, the quotes in industry media, your bar and community involvement. That is the raw material. If you have very little footprint, AI has very little to work with.
Even if your name appears in the answer, that alone does not guarantee you are on the real short list. It just means you might be in the research pile. The moment a human takes over, they go back to what people have always done. They ask around. “Do you know this lawyer.” “Has anyone worked with this firm.” “Who do you trust in this area.” The short list still gets built in conversations.
Picture a potential client sitting with a few names in front of them. Some came from AI, some from Google, some from memory. Before they decide, they will check with people they know. If your name is mentioned and the response is a shrug, that is not strong enough. If the response is, “Yes, I know her, she is smart and responsive and easy to work with,” that carries weight. If two different people say, “You should call him, he is the person I would hire,” you are no longer just a name on a screen, you are a trusted recommendation.
AI can whisper your name. Relationships get you vouched for.
This is why I keep coming back to human interaction. You do not need to become an influencer. You do not have to win some imaginary popularity contest. But if you want to win in a world where information is abundant, you must be known, not just listed.
Your job is to make it easy for both AI and humans to choose you. For AI to know you exist, you need a visible footprint. That means a clear, current bio that actually uses the words clients would search. It means articles and content that connect directly to your practice and the industries you serve. It means showing up in podcasts, panels, and associations where your name and your expertise are in context.
This is where my Lawyer Level Up work comes in. Business development today is not only about taking a client to lunch. It is the combined effect of visibility, reputation, and real relationships. AI should be able to answer, in a short paragraph, who you are, what you do, and who you serve. Humans should have real stories to tell when your name comes up. If you only focus on one side, you are leaving opportunities to someone else.
When the stakes are high, people do not hire a law firm because an algorithm suggested it. They hire based on trust. They may begin with AI research, but they finish with human judgment. The good news, especially for lawyers who do not see themselves as natural rainmakers, is that trust is built through a series of small, manageable actions. You show up at the industry event instead of skipping it. You join the committee and actually participate. You follow up with people you meet, even with a simple note or a shared resource. You make thoughtful introductions without expecting anything back right away.
Over time, these behaviors create a reputation. When someone asks, “Who should be on our short list,” your name comes easily to mind. AI might help them spell it correctly, but the reason they say it out loud is because of the relationship.
So here is the question to ask yourself. If a dream client used AI to research lawyers in your practice area today, would your name appear. And if it did, would anyone in their network enthusiastically confirm that you belong on the short list. If you hesitate on either answer, that is not a reason to beat yourself up. It is simply a clear starting point.
Invest in both sides. Build a visible, AI friendly footprint. Then double down on real human interaction. AI will become a bigger part of how clients gather information, but it will not get you on the short list. Relationships will.
***********************
Thom Singer, CSP, is a professional keynote speaker who speaker at law firm retreats. He also leads business development coaching for lawyers.